Are We Seeing the Start of a Tectonic Shift on Mandatory PDAAs in the Financial Services Field?

This article first appeared on Securities Arbitration Alert (SAA), here.

This is less a letter from the editor and more your editor’s musings, but I wonder whether we are seeing the start of a tectonic shift on mandatory predispute arbitration agreements (“PDAA”) in the financial services field?

For example:

  • As reported in SAAs 2021-13 (Apr. 5), -10 (Mar. 18), & -08 (Mar. 4), new SEC Chair Gary Gensler said at his March 2 Senate Banking Committee confirmation hearing that he was “open” to reconsidering the industry’s use of binding mandatory arbitration for resolving customer disputes. To me this indicates that the Commission will at a minimum exercise its Dodd-Frank section 921 authority to study securities arbitration.
  • As reported recently two major firms — Wells Fargo and Goldman Sachs — are rethinking PDAA use in the investor and employment realms, respectively.
  • The proposed FAIR Actwhich would among other things ban PDAA use in employment and investor contracts, is inexorably moving toward at least House passage. It already has 183 cosponsors.
  • As reported in SAA 2021-14 (Apr. 22), the Investor Choice Act of 2021 (“ICA”) was reintroduced April 15 by Jeff Merkley (D-OR) and by Rep. Bill Foster (D-IL). This iteration of the ICA – H.R. 2620 and S. 1171 – is essentially the same as the old one in that it would amend the FAA, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and the Investment Adviser Act of 1940, to ban the use of mandatory predispute agreements by broker-dealers and investment advisers and guarantee class action participation.
  • The new proposed ICA also retains a section from the last one amending the Securities Act of 1933 to state: “A security may not be registered with the Commission if the issuer, in its bylaws, registration statement, or other governing documents mandates arbitration for any disputes between the issuer and the shareholders of the issuer.”
  • Last, a bipartisan bill was introduced in the House April 30 that would bar application of mandatory predispute arbitration agreements to sexual assault claims. Specifically, Representatives Karen Bass (D-CA) and Debbie Lesko (R-AZ) introduced R. 2906, the purpose of which is: “To amend title 9 of the United States Code to prohibit the enforcement of predispute arbitration agreements with respect to sexual assault claims.”

As our editorial notes suggest, perhaps these BDs are trying to position themselves for a day when customer and/or employees will get to choose whether to agree to PDAAs? I also wonder whether other firms will follow suit. Time will tell….

author

George Friedman

George H. Friedman is the publisher and Editor-in-Chief of the Securities Arbitration Alert, a weekly online publication covering the latest developments in financial services arbitration and mediation. He is also the principal of George H. Friedman Consulting, LLC, providing expert advice on arbitration and mediation in general and the FINRA…

Featured Arbitrators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Arbitration Conversation No. 4: Amy Interviews Prof. Benjamin Davis of University of Toledo College of Law

In this episode Amy Schmitz interviews Ben Davis about diversity in arbitration, with a particular focus on the new Diversity and Inclusion Policy that was recently issued by ICCA (the...

By Benjamin Davis, Amy Schmitz
Category

Remember the FINRA Case Where the Broker Challenged a Zoom Hearing Ordered Over His Objection? It’s Been Awarded

This article first appeared on Securities Arbitration Alert (SAA), here. The arbitration underlying a suit challenging a FINRA Panel’s authority to hold a virtual hearing over a broker’s objection has been...

By George Friedman
Category

What Happens When an Arbitral Tribunal Makes a Mistake? Doglemor Trade Ltd v Caledor Consulting Ltd

This blog post was originally published on the Practical Law Arbitration Blog and is reproduced with the permission of Thomson Reuters. There are various means open to a party to an arbitration to seek...

By Paul Toms

Find an Arbitrator