Court Refuses to Vacate Award Stemming From Workplace Personal Injury

Aug 2021

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York recently refused to vacate an arbitration award stemming from a workplace personal injury after the arbitrator concluded that the employee was primarily responsible for his own injuries.

Daniel Pacelli was working for Vane Line Bunkering Inc. (known as “Vane Brothers”), as a tankerman on one of Vane Brothers’ barges in New York Harbor when he slipped, fell, and was injured on ice while attempting to salt the deck of the barge. He initiated an arbitration action against Vane Brothers. A JAMS arbitrator heard the case and concluded that Pacelli had sustained $986,750 in damages and that both Pacelli and Vane Brothers were negligent. More specifically, the arbitrator concluded that Pacelli was 70% at fault while Vane Brothers was 30% at fault. The arbitrator therefore reduced Pacelli’s damages accordingly. Pacelli moved to vacate the award….

Read the complete story here.

Read these next

Category

Arbitration Conversation No 60: Wendy Gonzales, Founder of Cyberarb

In this episode of the Arbitration Conversation Amy interviews Wendy Gonzales, Founder of Cyberarb (the Initiative for Cybersecurity in International Arbitration) as well as Disputes & Litigation Counsel at ASUS...

By Wendy Gonzales, Amy Schmitz
Category

Right to a Physical Hearing Project: The Release of 20 New Reports Reinforces Core Trends and Important Divergences

Several months ago, Co-editors Giacomo Rojas Elgueta, James Hosking and Yasmine Lahlou, in collaboration with ICCA, released a number of national reports regarding the right to a physical hearing. The...

By Stacie Strong
Category

Arbitration Conversation No. 46: Arbitrator, Mediator, and Trainer DeAndra Roaché of Cynergis ADR

In this episode of the Arbitration Conversation Amy interviews DeAndra Roaché, an experienced arbitrator, mediator, and trainer, as well as the founder of Cynergis ADR, about arbitration in the railroad...

By DeAndra Roaché, Amy Schmitz

Find an Arbitrator