Sixth Circuit Reverses District Court for Exceeding Its Authority by Ruling on Arbitrability…..

The plaintiff alleged that she was a victim of an illegal predatory loan orchestrated by the defendant’s company. The loan allegedly charged excessive interest but was shielded from U.S. law by tribal sovereign immunity.

The plaintiff filed suit, alleging that the loan was illegal and that the defendant had committed RICO and other consumer protection violations. The loan contract, however, included an arbitration provision, providing that “any dispute … related to this agreement will be resolved through binding arbitration” under tribal law, subject to review in tribal court. The defendant moved to compel arbitration, contending that the plaintiff agreed to a delegation clause to arbitrate issues “concerning the validity, enforceability, or scope” of the arbitration agreement, but the district court denied the defendant’s motion. The court found that the enforceability of the arbitration agreement “has already been litigated, and decided against [the defendant], in a similar case commenced in Vermont.”

Read the complete story here.

Featured Arbitrators

View all

Read these next


The Future of the Transportation Worker Exemption to Mandatory Arbitration – Clarity for the Gig Economy?

In 1925, the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”) was enacted to ensure the validity and enforcement of arbitration agreements due to a national policy favoring arbitration as a dispute resolution mechanism....

By Brittany Munn

What Happens When an Arbitral Tribunal Makes a Mistake? Doglemor Trade Ltd v Caledor Consulting Ltd

This blog post was originally published on the Practical Law Arbitration Blog and is reproduced with the permission of Thomson Reuters. There are various means open to a party to an arbitration to seek...

By Paul Toms

AAA ICDR Principles Supporting the Use of AI in Alternative Dispute Resolution

The American Arbitration Association®-International Centre for Dispute Resolution® (AAA-ICDR®) is committed to pioneering the thoughtful integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in alternative dispute resolution (ADR). We aim to enhance ADR...

By Colin Rule

Find an Arbitrator